Vote: The Top 50 Players not in the Hall of Fame

Quick Post:

Graham Womack from Baseball Past and Present recently posted a survey to determine the 50 best players not in the Hall of Fame, and asked voters to note if they think the player is Hall worthy.

Below is who I voted for:

Download (PDF, Unknown)

The toughest omissions for me were Dale Murphy, Thurman Munson, Dave Stieb, and Tommy John. I don’t think any of those guys belong in the Hall, but it was tough to leave them off the list above.

You can find more detailed analysis about most of the players on my list on posts throughout the site. Click around and check some of them out.

Graham’s survey is still open, so go ahead and vote!




  1. Ross Carey says:

    @baseballtwit We agree on 40/50 here is my list. (minus the thoughtful analysis you posted along with yours)

Leave a Reply